Protecting Students’ Privacy
July 17, 2020 01:54 PM to All House Members
Circulated By
Representative Gerald Mullery
D House District 119
Along With
Rep. Michael Schlossberg
D House District 132
Memo
In the age of advancing technology and easy access to the internet, we must be more vigilant than ever to ensure the privacy rights and overall safety of our children.
Currently, Pennsylvania’s Right to Know Law (RTKL) mandates access of public records, defining “public records” to include school surveillance videos. Due to the lack of clarification in our RTKL and privacy rights, cases, such as the recent Supreme Court Case, Easton Area School District v. Miller, the Court cited significant concerns over the absence of protection for school children.
The Supreme Court opinion noted that the ramifications are dangerous when school surveillance becomes subject to public disclosure without a parent’s consent, “such a disclosure could reveal the identity of minor-aged students; their clothing, behaviors, or disabilities; the specific bus they take; and the geographical location where they exit the bus.”
Despite the blatant disregard to student safety, the Court added that this public disclosure of student imagery additionally implicates a student’s right to privacy. The Supreme Court has called upon us as legislators to fix this overlook in our law and urged us as the General Assembly to, “undertake a review of the RTKL’s procedural provisions…to ensure the protection of the constitutional information privacy rights of third parties---in particular, those rights of public school students---when they are implicated by right to know requests.”
Please join me to ensure our students’ safety remains a priority across Pennsylvania.
Currently, Pennsylvania’s Right to Know Law (RTKL) mandates access of public records, defining “public records” to include school surveillance videos. Due to the lack of clarification in our RTKL and privacy rights, cases, such as the recent Supreme Court Case, Easton Area School District v. Miller, the Court cited significant concerns over the absence of protection for school children.
The Supreme Court opinion noted that the ramifications are dangerous when school surveillance becomes subject to public disclosure without a parent’s consent, “such a disclosure could reveal the identity of minor-aged students; their clothing, behaviors, or disabilities; the specific bus they take; and the geographical location where they exit the bus.”
Despite the blatant disregard to student safety, the Court added that this public disclosure of student imagery additionally implicates a student’s right to privacy. The Supreme Court has called upon us as legislators to fix this overlook in our law and urged us as the General Assembly to, “undertake a review of the RTKL’s procedural provisions…to ensure the protection of the constitutional information privacy rights of third parties---in particular, those rights of public school students---when they are implicated by right to know requests.”
Please join me to ensure our students’ safety remains a priority across Pennsylvania.
Legislation
Document - Introduced as HB 2754
Protecting Students’ Privacy
July 17, 2020 01:54 PM to All House Members
Circulated By
MULLERY and SCHLOSSBERG
Memo
In the age of advancing technology and easy access to the internet, we must be more vigilant than ever to ensure the privacy rights and overall safety of our children.
Currently, Pennsylvania’s Right to Know Law (RTKL) mandates access of public records, defining “public records” to include school surveillance videos. Due to the lack of clarification in our RTKL and privacy rights, cases, such as the recent Supreme Court Case, Easton Area School District v. Miller, the Court cited significant concerns over the absence of protection for school children.
The Supreme Court opinion noted that the ramifications are dangerous when school surveillance becomes subject to public disclosure without a parent’s consent, “such a disclosure could reveal the identity of minor-aged students; their clothing, behaviors, or disabilities; the specific bus they take; and the geographical location where they exit the bus.”
Despite the blatant disregard to student safety, the Court added that this public disclosure of student imagery additionally implicates a student’s right to privacy. The Supreme Court has called upon us as legislators to fix this overlook in our law and urged us as the General Assembly to, “undertake a review of the RTKL’s procedural provisions…to ensure the protection of the constitutional information privacy rights of third parties---in particular, those rights of public school students---when they are implicated by right to know requests.”
Please join me to ensure our students’ safety remains a priority across Pennsylvania.
Currently, Pennsylvania’s Right to Know Law (RTKL) mandates access of public records, defining “public records” to include school surveillance videos. Due to the lack of clarification in our RTKL and privacy rights, cases, such as the recent Supreme Court Case, Easton Area School District v. Miller, the Court cited significant concerns over the absence of protection for school children.
The Supreme Court opinion noted that the ramifications are dangerous when school surveillance becomes subject to public disclosure without a parent’s consent, “such a disclosure could reveal the identity of minor-aged students; their clothing, behaviors, or disabilities; the specific bus they take; and the geographical location where they exit the bus.”
Despite the blatant disregard to student safety, the Court added that this public disclosure of student imagery additionally implicates a student’s right to privacy. The Supreme Court has called upon us as legislators to fix this overlook in our law and urged us as the General Assembly to, “undertake a review of the RTKL’s procedural provisions…to ensure the protection of the constitutional information privacy rights of third parties---in particular, those rights of public school students---when they are implicated by right to know requests.”
Please join me to ensure our students’ safety remains a priority across Pennsylvania.
Document
Introduced as HB 2754
Generated 03/22/2025 09:23 AM