Protecting Children in Foster Care/Adoption - Grace Packer
September 7, 2021 12:33 PM to All House Members
Circulated By
Representative Craig Staats
R House District 145
Along With
Rep. Christopher Quinn
R House District 168
Memo
In the near future, we will introduce a legislative package that would help better protect children by updating Pennsylvania’s Child Protective Services Law (CPSL). This legislation, which is anticipated to be a package of three bills, is in memory of Grace Packer, a 14-year old girl brutally murdered in 2016 by her adoptive mother and her boyfriend. As reported by local, statewide and national media, Grace was adopted as a toddler by Sara Packer, a county adoption worker, and her then-husband David.
As a result of frequent moves, multiple county child welfare agencies (CCWA) and contractors of those agencies supervised Grace’s placement or had contact with the family. In July 2016, Grace was beaten and raped by Sara’s live-in boyfriend, Jacob Sullivan, while Sara watched. Strangled the next day by Sullivan, Grace’s body was dismembered and dumped in Luzerne County where hunters found it months later.
It was subsequently discovered the home was filled with relentless emotional, physical and sexual abuse. While a State Inspector General investigation regarding the failures of our child welfare system in this case is ongoing, Grace’s murder highlighted numerous gaps in our CPSL and the systems by which we track reports of child abuse. To better protect children like Grace, our bills will focus on three specific objectives as follows:
Statutory Requirement to Implement the Statewide Child Abuse Information System
In 2014, two years before Grace’s murder, the General Assembly enacted legislation mandating the development and implementation of a statewide child abuse database to replace the 67 county-based systems now in use. The Office of Children, Youth and Families in DHS is directing the establishment of this system. During budget hearings, the DHS Secretary indicated implementation of this system is not expected until 2023. Our legislation would require this system be brought online by the end of 2022.
Record Retention
Throughout the CPSL record retention is often at the discretion of CCWAs. To better protect children, this discretion must become a requirement. The CPSL is also without explicit language holding contractors of CCWAs and human service agencies to the same record retention requirements as the agencies themselves. Our legislation will address this and also require CCWAs and the PA Department of Human Services to designate an employee as “custodian of records,” with responsibility for record retention and making necessary amendments, expunctions, expungements and notifications as required by the CPSL.
“Valid” and “Invalid Reports”
Currently, the CPSL uses but does not define the terms “valid” and “invalid” in relation to a report of suspected abuse, nor does it provide any context where the terms are used that might suggest a meaning. It uses “founded,” “unfounded,” and “indicated.” Our legislation will address this inconsistency.
On August 14th of this year, Grace Packer should be celebrating her 20th birthday. Instead, it will be more than five years after her brutal murder. Not a single regulatory or statutory change has been made since her death.
Please join us in co-sponsoring this legislation that would better protect Pennsylvania children and help ensure our child welfare system never again fails a child as it failed Grace Packer.
As a result of frequent moves, multiple county child welfare agencies (CCWA) and contractors of those agencies supervised Grace’s placement or had contact with the family. In July 2016, Grace was beaten and raped by Sara’s live-in boyfriend, Jacob Sullivan, while Sara watched. Strangled the next day by Sullivan, Grace’s body was dismembered and dumped in Luzerne County where hunters found it months later.
It was subsequently discovered the home was filled with relentless emotional, physical and sexual abuse. While a State Inspector General investigation regarding the failures of our child welfare system in this case is ongoing, Grace’s murder highlighted numerous gaps in our CPSL and the systems by which we track reports of child abuse. To better protect children like Grace, our bills will focus on three specific objectives as follows:
Statutory Requirement to Implement the Statewide Child Abuse Information System
In 2014, two years before Grace’s murder, the General Assembly enacted legislation mandating the development and implementation of a statewide child abuse database to replace the 67 county-based systems now in use. The Office of Children, Youth and Families in DHS is directing the establishment of this system. During budget hearings, the DHS Secretary indicated implementation of this system is not expected until 2023. Our legislation would require this system be brought online by the end of 2022.
Record Retention
Throughout the CPSL record retention is often at the discretion of CCWAs. To better protect children, this discretion must become a requirement. The CPSL is also without explicit language holding contractors of CCWAs and human service agencies to the same record retention requirements as the agencies themselves. Our legislation will address this and also require CCWAs and the PA Department of Human Services to designate an employee as “custodian of records,” with responsibility for record retention and making necessary amendments, expunctions, expungements and notifications as required by the CPSL.
“Valid” and “Invalid Reports”
Currently, the CPSL uses but does not define the terms “valid” and “invalid” in relation to a report of suspected abuse, nor does it provide any context where the terms are used that might suggest a meaning. It uses “founded,” “unfounded,” and “indicated.” Our legislation will address this inconsistency.
On August 14th of this year, Grace Packer should be celebrating her 20th birthday. Instead, it will be more than five years after her brutal murder. Not a single regulatory or statutory change has been made since her death.
Please join us in co-sponsoring this legislation that would better protect Pennsylvania children and help ensure our child welfare system never again fails a child as it failed Grace Packer.
Legislation
Document 1 - Introduced as HB 1843
Description: Statutory Requirement to Implement the Statewide Child Abuse Information System
In 2014, two years before Grace’s murder, the General Assembly enacted legislation mandating the development and implementation of a statewide child abuse database to replace the 67 county-based systems now in use. The Office of Children, Youth and Families in DHS is directing the establishment of this system. During budget hearings, the DHS Secretary indicated implementation of this system is not expected until 2023. Our legislation would require this system be brought online by the end of 2022.
In 2014, two years before Grace’s murder, the General Assembly enacted legislation mandating the development and implementation of a statewide child abuse database to replace the 67 county-based systems now in use. The Office of Children, Youth and Families in DHS is directing the establishment of this system. During budget hearings, the DHS Secretary indicated implementation of this system is not expected until 2023. Our legislation would require this system be brought online by the end of 2022.
Document 2 - Introduced as HB 1844
Description: Record Retention
Throughout the CPSL record retention is often at the discretion of CCWAs. To better protect children, this discretion must become a requirement. The CPSL is also without explicit language holding contractors of CCWAs and human service agencies to the same record retention requirements as the agencies themselves. Our legislation will address this and also require CCWAs and the PA Department of Human Services to designate an employee as “custodian of records,” with responsibility for record retention and making necessary amendments, expunctions, expungements and notifications as required by the CPSL.
Throughout the CPSL record retention is often at the discretion of CCWAs. To better protect children, this discretion must become a requirement. The CPSL is also without explicit language holding contractors of CCWAs and human service agencies to the same record retention requirements as the agencies themselves. Our legislation will address this and also require CCWAs and the PA Department of Human Services to designate an employee as “custodian of records,” with responsibility for record retention and making necessary amendments, expunctions, expungements and notifications as required by the CPSL.
Document 3 - Introduced as HB 1845
Description: “Valid” and “Invalid Reports”
Currently, the CPSL uses but does not define the terms “valid” and “invalid” in relation to a report of suspected abuse, nor does it provide any context where the terms are used that might suggest a meaning. It uses “founded,” “unfounded,” and “indicated.” Our legislation will address this inconsistency.
Currently, the CPSL uses but does not define the terms “valid” and “invalid” in relation to a report of suspected abuse, nor does it provide any context where the terms are used that might suggest a meaning. It uses “founded,” “unfounded,” and “indicated.” Our legislation will address this inconsistency.
Last updated on September 7, 2021 12:35 PM
Protecting Children in Foster Care/Adoption - Grace Packer
September 7, 2021 12:33 PM to All House Members
Circulated By
STAATS and QUINN
Memo
In the near future, we will introduce a legislative package that would help better protect children by updating Pennsylvania’s Child Protective Services Law (CPSL). This legislation, which is anticipated to be a package of three bills, is in memory of Grace Packer, a 14-year old girl brutally murdered in 2016 by her adoptive mother and her boyfriend. As reported by local, statewide and national media, Grace was adopted as a toddler by Sara Packer, a county adoption worker, and her then-husband David.
As a result of frequent moves, multiple county child welfare agencies (CCWA) and contractors of those agencies supervised Grace’s placement or had contact with the family. In July 2016, Grace was beaten and raped by Sara’s live-in boyfriend, Jacob Sullivan, while Sara watched. Strangled the next day by Sullivan, Grace’s body was dismembered and dumped in Luzerne County where hunters found it months later.
It was subsequently discovered the home was filled with relentless emotional, physical and sexual abuse. While a State Inspector General investigation regarding the failures of our child welfare system in this case is ongoing, Grace’s murder highlighted numerous gaps in our CPSL and the systems by which we track reports of child abuse. To better protect children like Grace, our bills will focus on three specific objectives as follows:
Statutory Requirement to Implement the Statewide Child Abuse Information System
In 2014, two years before Grace’s murder, the General Assembly enacted legislation mandating the development and implementation of a statewide child abuse database to replace the 67 county-based systems now in use. The Office of Children, Youth and Families in DHS is directing the establishment of this system. During budget hearings, the DHS Secretary indicated implementation of this system is not expected until 2023. Our legislation would require this system be brought online by the end of 2022.
Record Retention
Throughout the CPSL record retention is often at the discretion of CCWAs. To better protect children, this discretion must become a requirement. The CPSL is also without explicit language holding contractors of CCWAs and human service agencies to the same record retention requirements as the agencies themselves. Our legislation will address this and also require CCWAs and the PA Department of Human Services to designate an employee as “custodian of records,” with responsibility for record retention and making necessary amendments, expunctions, expungements and notifications as required by the CPSL.
“Valid” and “Invalid Reports”
Currently, the CPSL uses but does not define the terms “valid” and “invalid” in relation to a report of suspected abuse, nor does it provide any context where the terms are used that might suggest a meaning. It uses “founded,” “unfounded,” and “indicated.” Our legislation will address this inconsistency.
On August 14th of this year, Grace Packer should be celebrating her 20th birthday. Instead, it will be more than five years after her brutal murder. Not a single regulatory or statutory change has been made since her death.
Please join us in co-sponsoring this legislation that would better protect Pennsylvania children and help ensure our child welfare system never again fails a child as it failed Grace Packer.
As a result of frequent moves, multiple county child welfare agencies (CCWA) and contractors of those agencies supervised Grace’s placement or had contact with the family. In July 2016, Grace was beaten and raped by Sara’s live-in boyfriend, Jacob Sullivan, while Sara watched. Strangled the next day by Sullivan, Grace’s body was dismembered and dumped in Luzerne County where hunters found it months later.
It was subsequently discovered the home was filled with relentless emotional, physical and sexual abuse. While a State Inspector General investigation regarding the failures of our child welfare system in this case is ongoing, Grace’s murder highlighted numerous gaps in our CPSL and the systems by which we track reports of child abuse. To better protect children like Grace, our bills will focus on three specific objectives as follows:
Statutory Requirement to Implement the Statewide Child Abuse Information System
In 2014, two years before Grace’s murder, the General Assembly enacted legislation mandating the development and implementation of a statewide child abuse database to replace the 67 county-based systems now in use. The Office of Children, Youth and Families in DHS is directing the establishment of this system. During budget hearings, the DHS Secretary indicated implementation of this system is not expected until 2023. Our legislation would require this system be brought online by the end of 2022.
Record Retention
Throughout the CPSL record retention is often at the discretion of CCWAs. To better protect children, this discretion must become a requirement. The CPSL is also without explicit language holding contractors of CCWAs and human service agencies to the same record retention requirements as the agencies themselves. Our legislation will address this and also require CCWAs and the PA Department of Human Services to designate an employee as “custodian of records,” with responsibility for record retention and making necessary amendments, expunctions, expungements and notifications as required by the CPSL.
“Valid” and “Invalid Reports”
Currently, the CPSL uses but does not define the terms “valid” and “invalid” in relation to a report of suspected abuse, nor does it provide any context where the terms are used that might suggest a meaning. It uses “founded,” “unfounded,” and “indicated.” Our legislation will address this inconsistency.
On August 14th of this year, Grace Packer should be celebrating her 20th birthday. Instead, it will be more than five years after her brutal murder. Not a single regulatory or statutory change has been made since her death.
Please join us in co-sponsoring this legislation that would better protect Pennsylvania children and help ensure our child welfare system never again fails a child as it failed Grace Packer.
Document 1
Description: Statutory Requirement to Implement the Statewide Child Abuse Information System
In 2014, two years before Grace’s murder, the General Assembly enacted legislation mandating the development and implementation of a statewide child abuse database to replace the 67 county-based systems now in use. The Office of Children, Youth and Families in DHS is directing the establishment of this system. During budget hearings, the DHS Secretary indicated implementation of this system is not expected until 2023. Our legislation would require this system be brought online by the end of 2022.
In 2014, two years before Grace’s murder, the General Assembly enacted legislation mandating the development and implementation of a statewide child abuse database to replace the 67 county-based systems now in use. The Office of Children, Youth and Families in DHS is directing the establishment of this system. During budget hearings, the DHS Secretary indicated implementation of this system is not expected until 2023. Our legislation would require this system be brought online by the end of 2022.
Introduced as HB 1843
Document 2
Description: Record Retention
Throughout the CPSL record retention is often at the discretion of CCWAs. To better protect children, this discretion must become a requirement. The CPSL is also without explicit language holding contractors of CCWAs and human service agencies to the same record retention requirements as the agencies themselves. Our legislation will address this and also require CCWAs and the PA Department of Human Services to designate an employee as “custodian of records,” with responsibility for record retention and making necessary amendments, expunctions, expungements and notifications as required by the CPSL.
Throughout the CPSL record retention is often at the discretion of CCWAs. To better protect children, this discretion must become a requirement. The CPSL is also without explicit language holding contractors of CCWAs and human service agencies to the same record retention requirements as the agencies themselves. Our legislation will address this and also require CCWAs and the PA Department of Human Services to designate an employee as “custodian of records,” with responsibility for record retention and making necessary amendments, expunctions, expungements and notifications as required by the CPSL.
Introduced as HB 1844
Document 3
Description: “Valid” and “Invalid Reports”
Currently, the CPSL uses but does not define the terms “valid” and “invalid” in relation to a report of suspected abuse, nor does it provide any context where the terms are used that might suggest a meaning. It uses “founded,” “unfounded,” and “indicated.” Our legislation will address this inconsistency.
Currently, the CPSL uses but does not define the terms “valid” and “invalid” in relation to a report of suspected abuse, nor does it provide any context where the terms are used that might suggest a meaning. It uses “founded,” “unfounded,” and “indicated.” Our legislation will address this inconsistency.
Introduced as HB 1845
Last Updated
September 7, 2021 12:35 PM
Generated 05/15/2025 12:12 AM