Certificate of Merit in Medical Liability Actions
March 8, 2024 09:56 AM to All Senate Members
Circulated By

Senator David Argall
R Senate District 29
Memo
In the early 2000’s, a medical liability crisis occurred in Pennsylvania which resulted in high liability premiums, the curtailing of high-risk services, and the closure of maternity wards across the Commonwealth. In order to address the situation, a series of legislative and judicial actions were taken in 2002, including the Certificate of Merit rule which requires any person who brings a claim against a medical professional to provide a certificate of merit either at the time of filing that claim with the Court or within sixty days of bringing the claim.
In August of 2022, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reversed a rule set in place 20 years ago which was credited with decreasing the number of frivolous lawsuits and bringing health care services back to people across the Commonwealth. In order to ensure that another medical liability crisis does not happen in Pennsylvania, I will introduce legislation to update the Medical Care Availability and Reduction Error Act in order to increase transparency on how claims of medical liability are reviewed on their merit.
Specifically, this legislation will do three main things:
Please join me in co-sponsoring this effort.
In August of 2022, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reversed a rule set in place 20 years ago which was credited with decreasing the number of frivolous lawsuits and bringing health care services back to people across the Commonwealth. In order to ensure that another medical liability crisis does not happen in Pennsylvania, I will introduce legislation to update the Medical Care Availability and Reduction Error Act in order to increase transparency on how claims of medical liability are reviewed on their merit.
Specifically, this legislation will do three main things:
- define and establish the credentials of a licensed professional who reviews a claim of medical liability;
- establish a process where the statement of the licensed professional who has reviewed the claim will be shared with the medical professional defending the claim and will require that the statement is shared at the time of filing the certificate of merit, regardless of whether an attorney or unrepresented party is the person who prepared the certificate of merit; and
- require, as part of the statement, that the licensed professional be identified, and their curriculum vitae be included as part of the certificate of merit filing.
Please join me in co-sponsoring this effort.
Legislation
Document - Introduced as SB 1182
Certificate of Merit in Medical Liability Actions
March 8, 2024 09:56 AM to All Senate Members
Circulated By
ARGALL
Memo
In the early 2000’s, a medical liability crisis occurred in Pennsylvania which resulted in high liability premiums, the curtailing of high-risk services, and the closure of maternity wards across the Commonwealth. In order to address the situation, a series of legislative and judicial actions were taken in 2002, including the Certificate of Merit rule which requires any person who brings a claim against a medical professional to provide a certificate of merit either at the time of filing that claim with the Court or within sixty days of bringing the claim.
In August of 2022, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reversed a rule set in place 20 years ago which was credited with decreasing the number of frivolous lawsuits and bringing health care services back to people across the Commonwealth. In order to ensure that another medical liability crisis does not happen in Pennsylvania, I will introduce legislation to update the Medical Care Availability and Reduction Error Act in order to increase transparency on how claims of medical liability are reviewed on their merit.
Specifically, this legislation will do three main things:
Please join me in co-sponsoring this effort.
In August of 2022, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reversed a rule set in place 20 years ago which was credited with decreasing the number of frivolous lawsuits and bringing health care services back to people across the Commonwealth. In order to ensure that another medical liability crisis does not happen in Pennsylvania, I will introduce legislation to update the Medical Care Availability and Reduction Error Act in order to increase transparency on how claims of medical liability are reviewed on their merit.
Specifically, this legislation will do three main things:
- define and establish the credentials of a licensed professional who reviews a claim of medical liability;
- establish a process where the statement of the licensed professional who has reviewed the claim will be shared with the medical professional defending the claim and will require that the statement is shared at the time of filing the certificate of merit, regardless of whether an attorney or unrepresented party is the person who prepared the certificate of merit; and
- require, as part of the statement, that the licensed professional be identified, and their curriculum vitae be included as part of the certificate of merit filing.
Please join me in co-sponsoring this effort.
Document
Introduced as SB 1182
Generated 05/16/2025 05:00 AM